You open your mortgage statement and your stomach drops. Your payment went up by $247. Nobody warned you. Nobody asked. It just... happened.
If this sounds familiar, you're not alone. I get calls about this every single January and February — right after annual escrow analyses go out. Last month alone, I talked to 14 homeowners who were blindsided by increases ranging from $89 to $612 per month.
The good news? You have more control over this than you think. In most cases, you can reduce or eliminate the increase. Let me walk you through exactly what happened, why, and what to do about it.
What Is an Escrow Account? (The 60-Second Version)
Your escrow account is a savings account managed by your mortgage servicer that pays your property taxes and homeowners insurance on your behalf. Each month, you pay 1/12th of your annual tax and insurance bills as part of your mortgage payment. Your servicer holds this money and pays the bills when they come due.
Think of it like a piggy bank your lender manages. Every month, they take a little bit extra on top of your principal and interest, stash it in the escrow account, and then pay your property taxes (usually twice a year) and homeowners insurance (once a year) when the bills arrive.
The problem? Those bills change every year. And when they go up, your monthly payment goes up too.
The 3 Real Reasons Your Escrow Payment Increased
I've reviewed thousands of escrow analyses over my career. The increase almost always comes down to one (or a combination) of these three things:
Property Taxes Went Up
This is the #1 reason, accounting for about 60% of escrow increases I see. Your county reassessed your home's value (probably because home prices in your area went up), and now your tax bill is higher. In 2025-2026, many counties are catching up on reassessments they delayed during COVID.
Real example: A client in Texas saw her property tax assessment jump from $285,000 to $342,000 — a 20% increase. Her annual property tax went from $6,840 to $8,208. That's an extra $1,368/year, or $114/month added to her escrow payment.
Homeowners Insurance Premium Increased
Insurance costs have been skyrocketing — up 23% nationally since 2023. If you live in Florida, Texas, California, Louisiana, or Colorado, you've probably been hit even harder. Climate-related claims, reinsurance costs, and inflation in building materials are all driving premiums up.
Real example: A homeowner in Florida saw their insurance go from $2,400/year to $4,100/year — a 71% increase. That's an extra $1,700/year, or $142/month added to escrow. Some Florida homeowners have seen increases of $300-$500/month just from insurance.
Escrow Shortage (You Were Underpaying)
Even if your taxes and insurance only went up a little, you might have a shortage — meaning your escrow account doesn't have enough money to cover the upcoming bills. This happens when last year's estimates were too low, or when your initial escrow setup at closing didn't account for the full annual cycle.
How it works: If your escrow account is $1,200 short, your servicer spreads that shortage over 12 months ($100/month) on top of the new higher monthly amount. So you're paying the increased cost PLUS making up the deficit. This is why increases feel so dramatic.
How to Read Your Escrow Analysis Statement (Step by Step)
Your servicer sends an annual escrow analysis statement — usually a 3-4 page document that looks like it was designed to confuse you. Here's how to decode it:
6 Proven Strategies to Lower Your Escrow Payment
Alright, here's the part you came for. These are the exact strategies I recommend to my clients, ranked from easiest to most impactful:
1. Pay the Escrow Shortage as a Lump Sum
This is the fastest fix. When you get your escrow analysis, it'll show a shortage amount — say, $1,800. By default, your servicer spreads that over 12 months ($150/month extra). But you can pay the $1,800 in one shot.
Result: Your monthly payment still goes up (because the underlying costs increased), but it goes up by much less — only the actual cost increase, not the shortage repayment.
Example: Your escrow analysis shows a $2,400 shortage and a new payment that's $350/month higher. If you pay the $2,400 lump sum, your increase drops to ~$150/month (just the actual cost increase). You just saved $200/month for the next year.
2. Appeal Your Property Tax Assessment
If your property taxes jumped because of a reassessment, you can fight it. And you should — about 40-60% of property tax appeals result in a reduction, according to the National Taxpayers Union.
Here's how: Contact your county assessor's office and request the appeal form (most are available online). You typically have 30-90 days from the assessment notice to file. Gather evidence: recent comparable sales that support a lower value, photos of any property issues (deferred maintenance, needed repairs), and if possible, a recent independent appraisal.
Pro tip: Look at what similar homes in your neighborhood actually sold for in the past 6 months. If your assessment is higher than recent sales, you have a strong case. Many counties will settle informally before a formal hearing — saving you time and hassle.
3. Shop Your Homeowners Insurance
This is the single biggest opportunity most homeowners miss. Insurance loyalty doesn't pay — in fact, existing customers often pay 15-30% more than new customers for the same coverage. I tell every client: shop your insurance every single year.
Get quotes from at least 5 carriers. Consider bundling with your auto insurance. Raise your deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 (this alone can save 10-15%). Ask about discounts for security systems, new roofs, and claims-free history.
If you find a cheaper policy, your new insurer will handle the switch. Then call your mortgage servicer and ask them to do a re-analysis of your escrow account with the new, lower insurance premium. Your payment should drop within 30-60 days.
Could Refinancing Lower Your Total Payment?
If your rate is above 6.5%, refinancing could save you more than fixing escrow alone. Check today's rates.
Check Refinance Rates →4. Request an Escrow Waiver (Remove Escrow Entirely)
If you have at least 20% equity and a solid payment history (no late payments in the past 12 months), you may be able to eliminate your escrow account entirely. This means you'd pay property taxes and insurance directly — on your own schedule.
The benefit: You control the money. No more surprises. No more shortages. You can shop insurance and pay taxes on your own timeline. Some people even earn interest on the money while it sits in their savings account.
The catch: Some lenders charge a small fee for escrow waivers (typically 0.125-0.25% added to your rate). And you need the discipline to save for those big bills yourself. FHA and VA loans generally don't allow escrow removal.
If you're considering this, talk to your lender about escrow waiver options — or compare lenders who offer this without extra fees.
5. Check for Escrow Analysis Errors
I cannot stress this enough: errors are common. In my experience, about 1 in 5 escrow analyses contain some kind of mistake. Common errors include:
- ⚠️Wrong property tax parcel number (you're paying someone else's taxes)
- ⚠️Duplicate insurance policies on file (old policy wasn't removed)
- ⚠️Incorrect tax assessment amount (using projected instead of actual)
- ⚠️Missing homestead exemption or senior exemption
- ⚠️Wrong county tax rate applied
- ⚠️Flood insurance included when you're not in a flood zone
Call your servicer and ask them to walk through the analysis line by line. If you find an error, request a corrected escrow analysis — they're required to provide one within 30 days.
6. Apply for Property Tax Exemptions
Many homeowners don't realize they qualify for tax exemptions that could save them hundreds or thousands per year:
| Exemption | Who Qualifies | Typical Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Homestead Exemption | Primary residence owners | $500-$5,000/year |
| Senior Citizen Exemption | Age 62-65+ (varies by state) | $1,000-$4,000/year |
| Veteran/Disability Exemption | Veterans, disabled homeowners | $1,500-$10,000/year |
| Agricultural Exemption | Rural property with ag use | 50-90% reduction |
| Energy Efficiency Exemption | Solar panels, green upgrades | $200-$1,500/year |
Check with your county assessor's office to see which exemptions you qualify for. Many can be filed online and take effect within one tax cycle.
Let's Do the Math: A Real Escrow Breakdown
Scenario: Your mortgage payment went from $2,100 to $2,450/month — a $350 increase.
If you pay the shortage lump sum ($2,400): Your increase drops from $350 to $150/month. That's $200/month saved, or $2,400/year — which is exactly what you paid upfront. After year one, you break even and keep the lower payment going forward.
When Refinancing Makes More Sense Than Fixing Escrow
Sometimes the escrow increase is just the wake-up call you needed to look at your overall mortgage situation. If your interest rate is above 6.5% and you have decent credit (680+), refinancing could save you far more than any escrow fix.
For example: Refinancing from 7.25% to 6.10% on a $350,000 loan saves about $280/month in principal and interest — which might more than offset the escrow increase entirely. Plus, you can restructure your escrow at the same time with the new lender.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did my escrow payment increase?
Property tax increases (60% of cases), homeowners insurance premium hikes (30%), or an escrow shortage from the previous year (10%). Your servicer adjusts your monthly payment annually to cover projected costs.
How much can escrow increase per year?
There's no federal cap — it depends on your actual tax and insurance costs. RESPA limits the escrow cushion to 2 months of payments. Increases of $100-$500/month are common in 2026.
Can I remove my escrow account?
If you have 20%+ equity and good payment history, many lenders allow escrow waivers. FHA and VA loans generally require escrow. Some lenders charge a small fee (0.125-0.25% rate increase).
Can I pay the escrow shortage in a lump sum?
Yes! This is the fastest way to reduce your monthly increase. Pay the shortage amount in full, and your payment only goes up by the actual cost increase — not the shortage repayment.
How do I appeal my property tax assessment?
File with your county assessor within 30-90 days of the notice. Provide comparable sales data and property condition evidence. 40-60% of appeals succeed, saving $1,000-$3,000/year on average.
Will my escrow payment ever go down?
Yes! If property taxes decrease (successful appeal), insurance premiums drop (shopping around), or you had a surplus from overpayment. Request a re-analysis after any cost reduction.
Lower Your Total Mortgage Payment
Compare refinance rates and find out if you can save more than just fixing escrow.
Compare Rates Now →