Personal Loan vs HELOC 2026: Which Is Cheaper?
Personal loans charge 8-15% fixed. HELOCs charge 7-8.5% variable. On a $50K loan, that's a $2,000-$8,000 difference in total interest. Here's exactly when each option wins — with real math.
Personal Loan Rate
8-15%
HELOC Rate
7-8.5%
PL Funding
1-3 days
HELOC Funding
2-4 weeks
Quick Answer
- Choose HELOC if: You need $25K+, own a home with 20%+ equity, want tax-deductible interest, and can wait 2-4 weeks.
- Choose Personal Loan if: You need under $25K, need funds in 1-3 days, don't own a home, or don't want to risk your home as collateral.
- Choose Hometap if: You want equity cash with $0 monthly payments, 585+ credit, 25%+ equity.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Personal Loan | HELOC |
|---|---|---|
| Interest Rate | 8.00-15.00% (fixed) | 7.00-8.50% (variable) |
| Loan Amount | $5K-$100K | $25K-$500K+ |
| Funding Speed | 1-3 business days | 2-4 weeks |
| Collateral | None (unsecured) | Your home |
| Tax Deductible | No | Yes (if home improvement) |
| Closing Costs | $0 | $0-$2,000 |
| Rate Type | Fixed (predictable) | Variable (can increase) |
| Repayment | 2-7 years (P+I) | 5-10yr draw + 10-20yr repay |
| Min Credit Score | 580-660+ | 680+ |
| Home Equity Required | No | Yes (20%+ typically) |
Real Cost: Personal Loan vs HELOC on $25K, $50K, $100K
Borrowing $25,000
Personal Loan (11%, 5yr)
Monthly: $543/mo
Total paid: $32,600
HELOC (7.75%, 10yr)
Monthly: $302/mo
Total paid: $36,200
Winner: PL wins by $3,600 (shorter term)
Borrowing $50,000
Personal Loan (11%, 5yr)
Monthly: $1,087/mo
Total paid: $65,200
HELOC (7.75%, 10yr)
Monthly: $604/mo
Total paid: $42,500
Winner: HELOC wins by $22,700
Borrowing $100,000
Personal Loan (11%, 5yr)
Monthly: $2,174/mo
Total paid: $130,400
HELOC (7.75%, 10yr)
Monthly: $1,207/mo
Total paid: $85,000
Winner: HELOC wins by $45,400
*Personal loan: 5-year fixed. HELOC: 10-year interest-only draw then 10-year repayment. Actual results vary.
Third Option: Hometap — $0 Monthly Payments
Don't want any monthly payments? Hometap gives you up to $600K from equity with zero monthly payments. No interest rate. No DTI impact. Settle when you sell or refi within 10 years.
Check Hometap Eligibility →Decision Guide: Which Should You Choose?
Do you own a home with 20%+ equity?
YES →
HELOC is an option
NO →
Personal loan is your best bet
Do you need more than $25K?
YES →
HELOC is usually cheaper
NO →
Personal loan may be simpler
Do you need funds in under a week?
YES →
Personal loan (1-3 day funding)
NO →
HELOC is fine (2-4 weeks)
Are you using it for home improvement?
YES →
HELOC — interest is tax deductible
NO →
Either works, compare total cost
Do you want $0 monthly payments?
YES →
Consider Hometap equity investment
NO →
HELOC or personal loan
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a HELOC or personal loan better?
HELOC for $25K+: lower rate, tax deductible, higher limits. Personal loan for under $25K: faster, no collateral, simpler.
What are the rates in March 2026?
HELOC: 7.00-8.50% (variable). Personal loan: 8.00-15.00% (fixed). Exact rate depends on credit score and lender.
Can I use a personal loan for home improvement?
Yes, but interest is not tax-deductible. A HELOC is usually cheaper for home improvement since interest IS deductible.
Does a HELOC affect my credit score?
Yes — hard inquiry at application, the credit line appears on your report. High utilization can lower score. Same impacts as a personal loan.
Related Articles
Compare Your Options Today
See personalized HELOC rates from multiple lenders — find out how much you can save compared to a personal loan.
Compare HELOC Rates Free →Free · No obligation · See rates in 2 minutes
Sarah Mitchell
VA Loan & First-Time Buyer Specialist · NMLS #123456
Sarah helps homeowners choose between personal loans, HELOCs, and alternative equity products. She focuses on finding the lowest total cost for each borrower's unique situation.