Mortgage Broker vs Bank 2025: Which Is Better for Your Home Loan?

Should you get your mortgage through a bank or a broker in 2025? Here’s a clear, unbiased comparison to help you get the best rate, the fastest approval, and the right loan program for your situation.

Quick Answer

Best Rates: Often a broker (shops multiple lenders)
Fastest Close: Often a bank you already use
More Programs: Usually a broker (FHA/VA/USDA, non-QM, Jumbo)
Best for Complex Files: Broker (more flexibility)

Broker vs Bank: Key Differences

Mortgage Broker

Shops multiple wholesale lenders for you
Access to more niche programs (self-employed, bank statements, non-QM)
May charge broker fee; often offset by lender credit

Bank/Lender

Single set of products and pricing
Familiarity, branch access, and potential relationship discounts
May have stricter overlays and slower turn times

Ready to Compare Options?

See loan options from multiple lenders and find the best rate for your profile.

See Loan Options

Who Wins by Scenario?

First-time buyer, low down payment (FHA): Broker
VA loan: Tie — choose by rate/fees and experience
USDA rural: Broker (program access varies by bank)
Jumbo (high-priced markets): Broker (more investor options)
Self-employed or variable income: Broker (alt-doc options)
Existing bank relationship + simple file: Bank may be faster

Fees and Rate Transparency

Always ask for a loan estimate and compare APRs, lender credits, and discount points. Brokers can often negotiate credits that offset third-party fees; banks may offer relationship credits.