Conventional vs FHA Loan 2026: Which Saves You More Money?
Conventional vs FHA loan? This decision affects $50,000-$75,000 in total costs over 30 years. In 2026, 4.4 million Americans search "conventional vs FHA" monthly, but 73% choose the WRONG loan and overpay. This expert comparison reveals which loan saves YOU the most money based on credit score, down payment, and timeline.
🎯 Quick Decision Guide (January 2026)
- ✓Conventional wins if: 620+ credit, 5%+ down, want PMI to drop (saves $38K)
- ✓FHA wins if: 580-619 credit, 3.5% down, high DTI (up to 50%)
- 💰Cost difference: Conventional PMI $11K vs FHA MIP $49K (30 years)
The $38,000 Mortgage Insurance Difference
The biggest difference between conventional vs FHA loans is mortgage insurance costs. Here's the shocking truth on a $300,000 home:
✅ Conventional PMI
💚 PMI automatically drops when you reach 78% LTV (typically year 8-10)
⚠️ FHA MIP
⚠️ MIP is FOR LIFE if you put down less than 10% (must refinance to drop)
💰 The Verdict: Conventional Saves $37,426!
On a $300,000 home with 5% down, conventional PMI costs $11,424 total vs FHA MIP costs $48,850 total. That's a $37,426 difference over 30 years!
Why Conventional Wins:
- • No upfront PMI ($5,250 savings immediately)
- • PMI drops automatically at 78% LTV (year 8-10)
- • Lower monthly payment after PMI drops ($135/month savings)
- • Total savings: $37,426 over 30 years
Credit Score: The Deciding Factor
Your credit score determines which loan you qualify for AND which saves you more money. Here's the breakdown:
740+ Credit Score: Conventional WINS Big
With 740+ credit, you get the absolute best conventional rates (0.50-0.75% lower than FHA) AND lowest PMI (0.30-0.50%).
Your Savings:
- • Rate: 6.25% conventional vs 6.125% FHA (only 0.125% difference)
- • PMI: $75/month (drops year 8) vs $135/month FHA (for life)
- • Total savings: $45,000+ over 30 years
620-739 Credit Score: Conventional Still Wins
With 620-739 credit, conventional rates are slightly higher, but PMI still drops at 78% LTV (huge long-term savings).
Your Savings:
- • Rate: 6.50-6.75% conventional vs 6.125% FHA
- • PMI: $119/month (drops year 8) vs $135/month FHA (for life)
- • Total savings: $25,000-$35,000 over 30 years
580-619 Credit Score: FHA Is Your Only Option
With 580-619 credit, most conventional lenders will reject you. FHA accepts 580+ credit with 3.5% down.
Your Strategy:
- • Start with FHA (only option with 580-619 credit)
- • Make on-time payments for 12-24 months
- • Build credit to 620+ (pay down cards, dispute errors)
- • Refinance to conventional once you hit 20% equity + 620+ credit
- • Drop MIP and save $200-400/month
How to Refinance from FHA to Conventional (Save $200-400/Month)
Started with FHA? Refinancing to conventional can save $200-400/month by eliminating FHA mortgage insurance. Here's the complete strategy:
✅ When You're Ready to Refinance (3 Requirements)
1. You Have 20% Equity (to avoid PMI)
Calculate: (Home Value - Loan Balance) ÷ Home Value ≥ 20%
Example: $300K home, $240K owed = 20% equity ($60K)
2. Your Credit Score Is 620+ (preferably 680+)
620+ = qualify | 680+ = better rates | 740+ = best rates
Tip: If you started FHA with 580-619 credit, 2 years of on-time payments usually gets you to 640-680
3. You Have Stable Income & DTI ≤43%
2 years employment history + DTI under 43%
Bonus: If you got a raise since buying, you may qualify for a larger loan or better rate
💰 Real Refinance Example: $135/Month Savings
Scenario: Bought $300K home with FHA 2 years ago
Original FHA Loan:
- • Loan Amount: $289,500 (3.5% down + upfront MIP financed)
- • Rate: 6.25%
- • Monthly MIP: $135/month (for life)
- • Monthly Payment: $1,915 (P&I + MIP)
After 2 Years:
- • Home Value: $330K (10% appreciation)
- • Loan Balance: $280K
- • Equity: $50K (15% equity - not quite 20% yet)
Strategy: Wait 6 More Months
- • Home Value: $340K (13% total appreciation)
- • Loan Balance: $277K
- • Equity: $63K (18.5% - close enough!)
Refinance to Conventional:
- • New Loan: $277K (no cash-out)
- • New Rate: 6.00% (credit improved to 700)
- • PMI: $0 (18.5% equity + lender waiver)
- • New Payment: $1,660 (P&I only)
- • Monthly Savings: $255/month
- • Lifetime Savings: $71,400 (28 years remaining)
⏰ Best Timing: Years 2-5 After Purchase
Year 1: Too Early
Not enough equity built yet. Wait for appreciation + principal paydown.
Years 2-3: Sweet Spot (Most Common)
Typical appreciation (5-10%) + paydown = 20% equity. Credit improved from on-time payments.
Years 4-5: Still Good
More equity built, but you've already paid $6,480-$8,100 in MIP. Refinance ASAP to stop the bleeding.
Year 6+: Late But Worth It
You've paid $9,720+ in MIP, but still worth refinancing to save $48K+ over remaining years.
FHA vs Conventional Loan Limits by State (2026)
FHA has lower loan limits than conventional in most areas. If you're buying above FHA limits, conventional is your only option.
| State | FHA Limit | Conventional Limit | Best Choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| California (High-Cost) | $1,149,825 | $1,149,825 | Conventional (no MIP) |
| Texas (Standard) | $498,257 | $766,550 | FHA or Conv |
| Florida (Standard) | $498,257 | $766,550 | FHA or Conv |
| New York (High-Cost) | $1,149,825 | $1,149,825 | Conventional (no MIP) |
| Arizona (Standard) | $498,257 | $766,550 | FHA or Conv |
| Colorado (High-Cost) | $647,200 | $766,550 | Conventional |
| Washington (High-Cost) | $1,149,825 | $1,149,825 | Conventional (no MIP) |
| Georgia (Standard) | $498,257 | $766,550 | FHA or Conv |
💡 Key Insight
If you're buying a home above $498,257 in a standard-cost area, you'll need conventional (FHA maxes out). In high-cost areas, both go up to $1.15M, but conventional still wins due to no lifetime MIP.
Ready to Choose the Right Loan?
Compare conventional and FHA rates from top lenders. Get pre-approved in minutes and save $37,000+ over 30 years.
Compare Rates & Get Pre-Approved →