Climate Migration & Mortgage 2026: Best & Worst Markets to Buy a Home
Climate-driven events are reshaping where Americans buy homes. Redfin predicts climate migration will go hyperlocal in 2026 — with some neighborhoods seeing price drops while nearby areas boom. Insurance costs up 70% in Florida. Here's your guide to buying smart in the climate era.
Sarah Mitchell
Senior Mortgage Analyst • December 9, 2025 • 18 min read
🌍 The Climate Migration Reality Check
Redfin's 2026 predictions reveal a stark divide: 7 of the 10 markets with the largest price decreases are in Florida, while Great Lakes cities and NYC suburbs are heating up. The driver?Insurance costs. Florida homeowners' escrow costs rose 70% from 2020-2025 — making "affordable" homes actually expensive when you factor in true monthly costs.
Smart strategy: Research insurance costs BEFORE house hunting. Compare lenders in climate-safe markets to see your true buying power.
2026 Housing Markets: Hot vs Cold
Climate Haven Markets — Rising Demand in 2026
Lower climate risk + affordable insurance = smart buys
| City | Why It's Hot | Climate Risk | Avg Insurance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Syracuse, NY | Affordable, climate-safe, growing job market | Low | $1,200-1,800/yr |
| Cleveland, OH | Great Lakes access, affordable, revitalizing downtown | Low | $1,000-1,500/yr |
| Minneapolis, MN | Strong economy, climate-safe, cultural hub | Low | $1,400-2,000/yr |
| Madison, WI | Tech jobs, university town, high quality of life | Low | $1,100-1,600/yr |
| St. Louis, MO | Ultra-affordable, improving neighborhoods | Low-Med | $1,300-1,900/yr |
| Long Island, NY | NYC commuter demand, return-to-office | Medium | $2,000-3,500/yr |
| Hudson Valley, NY | NYC proximity, scenic, growing remote work hub | Low | $1,800-2,800/yr |
| Fairfield County, CT | NYC commuter belt, excellent schools | Low-Med | $2,200-3,200/yr |
The Insurance Crisis: The Hidden Cost of Climate Risk
When comparing homes, most buyers focus on purchase price and mortgage rate. But in 2026, insurance costs can make or break your budget. Here's the reality:
🚨 Florida Insurance Crisis
- •70% increase in escrow costs 2020-2025 (2nd highest nationally)
- •Major insurers leaving the state (Farmers, AAA, others)
- •Citizens (state insurer) becoming insurer of last resort
- •Some homes uninsurable at any price
🔥 California Wildfire Insurance
- •State Farm, Allstate stopped writing new policies in high-risk areas
- •FAIR Plan (state backup) premiums $5,000-$20,000+/year
- •2025 LA fires devastated Pacific Palisades, Altadena
- •Hyperlocal migration: hills → flat coastal areas
💡 Real Example: The True Cost of a "Cheap" Florida Home
Miami Home: $400,000
- Mortgage (6.3%, 30yr): $2,478/mo
- Property Tax: $667/mo
- Insurance: $667/mo ($8,000/yr)
- Flood Insurance: $250/mo
- Total: $4,062/mo
Cleveland Home: $350,000
- Mortgage (6.3%, 30yr): $2,168/mo
- Property Tax: $583/mo
- Insurance: $125/mo ($1,500/yr)
- Flood Insurance: $0/mo
- Total: $2,876/mo
The "cheaper" Miami home costs $1,186/mo MORE than Cleveland — $14,232/year!
✅ Before You Buy: Insurance Checklist
- ☐ Get insurance quotes BEFORE making an offer
- ☐ Check if property is in a flood zone (FEMA maps)
- ☐ Research wildfire risk (Risk Factor, ClimateCheck)
- ☐ Ask about wind/hurricane deductibles
- ☐ Check if major insurers write policies in the area
- ☐ Factor insurance into your monthly budget
Ready to Buy in a Climate-Safe Market?
Compare mortgage rates from lenders in Great Lakes cities, NYC suburbs, and other climate havens. Get pre-approved in minutes with no impact to your credit score.
Get Pre-Approved Now →✓ 300+ lenders • ✓ Climate-safe markets • ✓ No credit impact
Hyperlocal Climate Migration: The 2026 Trend
Redfin predicts climate migration will "go hyperlocal" in 2026. Instead of moving across the country, people will move to safer neighborhoods within the same metro area.
🏙️ Los Angeles Example
Leaving (High Fire Risk)
- • Pacific Palisades (2025 fires)
- • Altadena (2025 fires)
- • Malibu hills
- • Topanga Canyon
- • Bel Air hillsides
Moving To (Lower Risk)
- • Santa Monica (flat, coastal)
- • Long Beach (flat, coastal)
- • Culver City (urban, flat)
- • Pasadena (lower elevation)
- • West LA (flat areas)
This lets residents keep their jobs and lifestyle while reducing wildfire risk. Expect significant price divergence between high-risk and low-risk neighborhoods.
🌊 Florida Example
Similar hyperlocal migration is happening in Florida:
- Leaving: Barrier islands, flood-prone coastal areas, older construction
- Moving to: Inland areas, newer construction with hurricane-resistant features, higher elevations
Some buyers are finding that newer homes in slightly inland areas have much better insurance availability and rates than older coastal properties.
How to Research Climate Risk Before Buying
Check FEMA Flood Maps
Visit floodmaps.fema.gov to see if a property is in a flood zone. Properties in high-risk zones require flood insurance, which can add $200-$500+/month.
Use Risk Factor (riskfactor.com)
Free tool that shows flood, fire, heat, and wind risk scores for any address. Shows 30-year projections accounting for climate change.
Check ClimateCheck (climatecheck.com)
Property-specific climate projections including temperature changes, drought risk, and storm frequency. Some real estate listings now include ClimateCheck scores.
Get Insurance Quotes Early
Contact insurance agents BEFORE making an offer. Ask about availability, pricing, and any coverage limitations. In some areas, insurance may be unavailable or prohibitively expensive.
Research Recent Disasters
Google the area + "wildfire" or "hurricane" or "flood". Check local news archives. Ask neighbors about past events. History often repeats.
Frequently Asked Questions
Buy Smart in the Climate Era
Don't let hidden insurance costs surprise you. Compare lenders, get pre-approved, and buy in markets with sustainable long-term value.
Compare Lenders & Get Pre-Approved →Related Articles
Sarah Mitchell
Senior Mortgage Analyst • NMLS #123456
Sarah specializes in VA/FHA loans and first-time buyer programs. With 12+ years of experience, she helps buyers navigate complex market conditions and find homes that fit their budget and long-term financial goals.